Friday, March 29, 2019

The communication quality between doctor and foreign patient

The dialogue shade among deposit and external enduring1. entranceWhile traveling is getting easier and migration is taking place frequently, cultural differences and dialogue problems have emerged as a new problem of today. The to the highest degree important case communication is inevitable for a non- peacher of the endemic lecture is cosmos a long-suffering. Some undesirable out finds may occur if the patient lav non give the correct training. With the recent migrations in the western countries much(prenominal) as Germany, France, the States, Canada, UK, Holland the number of non-speakers of the native phrase has become noneworthy. In misfire, in that location is withal an increase in the number of external patients with the real dry land sales to the immaterialers in the places much(prenominal) as Antalya and Bodrum. On the different hand, highly qualified healthc atomic number 18 professionals and competitive pricing increased the kick of health tourism in the whole tourism income (http//www. medical examination checkuptourisminturkey.org). On the establish of the importance of communication, concord to various resources, 80% of the medical mistakes atomic number 18 ca employ by giving incorrect information 13,8. Having gained much and more importance recently, hostile patient-doctor communication and the gaps it has, get out be evaluated with the view of experience management, and fin altogethery, the order real to prevent the incorrect information translation entrust be introduced.2. unrestrictedations Review Foreign patients do not know the topical anesthetic dustup and in that locationfore the speech of the doctor is analyzed in detail. 1,2,10,14 In the creation of this ruminate, lies the increase in the number of the non-speakers of the delivery of migrated country. For example in USA, 18% of people older than 5 years speak an other language at their home (U.S. Census Bureau 2002 QT-P16, cited i n leeward 20033). This information takes place in the article of Alexander and friends (2009) that contains interesting data nigh the non-speakers of native language In Geneva, Switzerland, 43% of the population is abroad natural and about 25% of the population speaks a language other than French at home.2.1. Culture Edward Tylors definition is cited as the prototypical definition of finale15. Tylor(1903/1988) defines as destination or civilization, taken in its wide ethnographic sense, is that intricate whole which includes noesis, belief, art, morals, law, custom, and other capabilities and habits acquired by man as a ingredient of society.As one of the famous authors who has decoded the most about his studies on market-gardening, Hofstede (20054) defines culture as the collective programming of the header which distinguishes the members of one group or category of people from another. According to these definitions, language is critical for twain underlined words. Capabilities are built by interpretation of language. Collective programming of mind programming codes are generated by language. We back end say that culture is created by language. The effects of culture on health care are standardized to those of language. For example in Turkey (strong uncertainty avoidance and collectivist culture) women are willing to be consulted to a woman obstetrician ( H2 infirmary film director of look Department), in USA (weak uncertainty avoidance and individualist ) there is no such problems. According Collins et al. (2002, cited in Lee 20035) utile communication between patient and doctor is critical to good medical outcomes. So a woman patient form a diametric culture may affect the medical outcomes. In literature, several topic 2,6 use language and culture interchangeable but in this theme we will use the language as creator of culture.2.2. Developed Methods To leave Trough The Language BarrierInformation transfer (communication) between a pa tient and a doctor is generated in two ways. If the patient and the doctor speak the same language and their cultures are close to each other the transfer is realised directly. If there are differences in the language and the culture of patient and doctor, a proxy is used. Followings are the proxies developed in the internet site if the patients do not know the local language Going to infirmary with a friend or relative who knows local language and victimisation him or her as translator. -In the deep interviews done with medical firmament workers, most of the alieners live in Turkey use this method, but if the friend or relative in the role of translator does not know the local language so much then some problems may emerge. representative establishes the communication between patient and doctor. -This method is specially used in private health care enterprises in Turkey. Because of cost, increasing effects, interpreters are not chosen by patients who have no good economic welf are. In many countries the language requirements of interpreters are not defined, and non-medical professional interpreters are used widely. In the study of Karliner et al.(2007) professional interpreters are associated with mendd clinical care more than is use of ad hoc interpreters, and professional interpreters appear to increase the quality of clinical care for modified English proficiency(LEP) patients to approach or couple that for patient without language barriers. Also many studies showed that professional interpreters who do not know the culture of the patient may offend the patient and the patient may lose confidence 3 .- Translation of those who are not medical rung -This type of translation is more common among immigrants. Because of large song of Turks living in Germany, it is quite probable to find non-medical staff that knows Turkish in the infirmary.- If the medical staff knows foreign language. -The manager of public hospital and the managers of H1 and H2 hos pitals said that the most important communication problem of medical sector is medical staffs without foreign language.- In these studies low content rates of the patients raise be seen. The most satisfactory method is bilingual staff and the least one is translation of relatives/friends of the patient. 3. Data and MethodThe aim of this paper is to improve communication quality between doctor and foreign patient. The research top dog is How can we improve the communication quality between doctor and foreign patient? Yin (1994) defined a case study as an falsifiable inquiry that investigates a contemporary phenomenon within its real-life linguistic context, especially when the boundaries between phenomenon and context are not clearly evident. Kohn(1997) states that Yin suggests the methodology may actually be more powerful for ex stick outatory purposes in its ability to answer questions of how and wherefore. In this paper by the definition of case study methods and the organise of the research question. Semi-structured interviews and observations are used for data collection and case study method is used for analyzing data.3.1. Selecting CasesIn Turkey there are 5 types of hospital. H1 private and multi branch, H2 private unique branch, H3 private, multi branch and foundation supported ,H4 public hospital, H5 university hospital. Cluster sampling method is used because population is heterogeneous. The population is first divided into separate groups of elements which is called as clusters, H1, H2, H3, H4, H5. A sampling from the hospitals in inspection and repair in different cities, eager to provide data and kn profess as the best in their cluster, is generated. As some hospitals demanded during the negotiations, the clusters they belong to are mentioned alternatively of their names. Table 3 -Hospital Characteristics in each ClusterCluster come in Staff (approximately)Total BranchIs there a department for foreign patient?InformantH1750017YHospital Dire ctor(M.D), Professor of PhysicalMedicine andRehabilitationH24501NDirector of Quality Department, Head of Nursing Department, need Doctor(M.D), unavoidableness Nurse, Senior Staff of Public RelationH38004N medical examination Director(M.D), Manager of Human ResourcesH416001NHead of Nursing Department, Emergency Doctor(M.D), Emergency Nurse,H5More than 10.0001NEmergency Doctor1(M.D), Emergency Doctor2(M.D),3.2. Problems with patients who do not know Turkish In some regions of Turkey, there are people who do not know the native language. We see that normally a relative or a friend of the patient wait on the communication as a translator (H1 Professor of PhysicalMedicine andRehabilitation). During the deep interviews with H3 medical examination Director, he says Citizens from the eastern region of our country, and immigrants from Iraq, Afghanistan, and Africa come to hospital when they are ill, with a relative or a friend of them and we intervene the patients with the translation of these people. The work at goes on in two ways for the non-citizen patients. If the patient can speak English as the public relations, nurses or the doctor can, the communication is established with the help of staff. But if the patient speaks a language other than the staff can do, then a translator is required. Hospital Director in H1 hospital stated thatThe number of our foreign patients that become ill in Turkey is little(prenominal) than the patients that was ill before coming to Turkey. We sent our doctors to other countries and enable them to meet doctors working in clinics and hospitals. In the next step, foreign doctor sends his/her patient to us. Before the patient arrives, we get the tests and diagnosing utilise to the patient. We meet the patient at the airport and accommodate the patient according to his/her economic welfare. All the transportation and other needs of the patient are met by our department established for this purpose. Taking into consideration the countries most foreign patients come from, we employ that staffs who know their language. Because the number of foreign patients in H1 hospital is more than other private and public hospitals, many applications were developed in accordance with the needs. For example, if the patient gets helpless anywhere in the hospital and shows the calling card given to him/her to any hospital employee the problem is workd. In the frame of JCI accreditation, the patients and employee are not quested to identify themselves according to their direction number. For the probability of being lost in the hospital mostly used sentences takes place in Turkish and in the language of the patient. When patient shows his or her need in bear language, the Turkish translation takes place under it then the communication is established. In H2, H3, H4, H5 hospitals, patients usually come after they get ill in Turkey. Quality manager of H2 hospital Our patients usually come us after an nausea in Turkey or according to the recommendation of their acquaintance who were convenient from our service. Among our patients, there is a group which establishes contact with us before they come to examination and shows the previous cure documents, and the other group comes without any plan or foreknowledge. In 2007 the distribution of the foreign patients came to H2 hospital is as follows many an(prenominal) demographic features of the patients are 64% are men and 36% women. 52% paid cash, 26% used assurance and 21% cured for melt by the hospital. Foreign patient level in all hospitals is about 1%. If we consider the graphic which Hofstede(2005191) has drawn according to the cultures of the countries The patients coming to H2 hospital take place in all four areas. These patients took service in 15 different departments. In communication with these patients, proxies were used. In 2007 H1 hospitals foreign patients came from 69 different countries such as Afghanistan, Argentina, Germany, A ngola, Albania, Austria, Azerbaijan, Kazakhstan, Russia, UK, USA, Canada, Finland, Czech Republic, India, Iraq, Iran, Vietnam, Uruguay shortly all quadrants of Hofstedes culture dimentions. In literature LEP (limited English proficiency) concept is used but limited Turkish proficiency, limited Arabic proficiency, limited Chinese proficiency are also problem. When we look at the problems about the culture and language, the cases in USA and Europe countries are common for all countries and should be solved in all countries. In mostly used method, victimization proxy, the main problem is the transfer of the knowledge. experience changes while transferring from one place to another, so knowledge can not be transferred but translated. For example in communication with simultaneous translation the question of Turk doctor Neyin var? is translated as what is defame?or obligation word is used. But the purpose here is to ask What seems your chief complaint today? In the article of Holden et al(2004) which includes usual examples, the avocation part takes place For example, Japanese speakers of English are influenced by the notions of politeness. sort of than categorically refusing a request, Japanese might say Ill appreciate about it (which means there is no way I am going to do anything about it. or, often with a great suck of breath between clenched teeth Thats very difficult, meaning that something is a sheer impossibility.3.3. Specific SituationPatient Name Y.S. Year 2008 epoch 48 Nationality Greece The patient comes to Bursa because of the dead of a friend of him. He goes to tinge with stomach ache. He is alone. The patient speaks English and Greek. After he turns to information desk, he is taken to the emergency doctor. The emergency doctor knows only Turkish. A professional interpreter is called. Patient tells the interpreter that when he first comes to the emergency he could not express himself to the hospital employee and he needs fast cure. In ma ke forition, he says that he was depressed even before the therapy and if he didnt have to, he would not come to a Turkish doctor.(Interpreter, H2 hospital Emergency Doctor(M.D), Emergency Nurse, Senior Staff of Public Relation) As we can understand from these expressions the patient has a negative point of view against Turkey because of the dreary events between Turkey and Greece in the past. This point of view is considered as a code given form the society he lived since his childhood 18 As the patient has to wait despite the emergency, he uses accusatory expressions. He says that the doctor in the emergency is young and inexperienced. That the translator is easy-going and that he mentions the negative behaviors of the patient after the examination has been an important factor in the success of the treatment. After the therapy blood test and abdominal USG are demanded. consequently gastroenteritis is diagnosed and his prescription was filled. (Emergency Doctor) After making a good bargain, patient lowers the price and pays in cash.(H2 Director of Quality Department) Because of the proximity of a less individualist society and relatively low prices in Turkey, the patients says that he also has a tooth ache and wants to see the therapy room for teeth. After seeing the room he takes a tooth therapy, as well.4. Solution In this article we stated that knowledge is translated not transferred. Culler(1982) states that each accord is a mis rationality.4. If every understanding is a misunderstanding then communication between different cultures using different proxies is a distorted understanding. To establish the communication in mother language gains importance. Communication between physicians and patients is fundamental for medical care.(Joos et al.1996, cited in Lee et al. 2003). The solutions are developed in a way that the patients take less time of the proxies. Physician reads the report in his/her give language both audibly and visually, and may al so provide videos and audios in the language of the patient5,19. The method developed in the scope of this article is a little more different. Native speaker doctors prepared the questions for diagnosis in their confess language as well as the answers to such questions. Until the diagnosis the patient chooses the questions in own language then physician and patient gets the printouts in their own languages. The forgotten point in the developed audio and video base system is, while answering physicians question without the system patient uses own language and physician does not understand. Videos are important in unidirectional communication as giving information about how the test will be done like as urine test. How can we solve communication problems between foreign patient and doctor? Can XML be a solution? XML is defined by the W3C Extensible Markup Language (XML) is a simple, very flexible text format .Originally designed to meet the challenges of big electronic publishin g, XML is also playing an increasingly important role in the exchange of a wide variety of data on the network and elsewhere (http//www.w3.org/XML) We can use xml for information transfer from one language to another one. We use transfer because native speaker doctors prepared the questions for diagnosis in their own language as well as the answers to such questions. Foreign patient and doctor use software in their own language, culture and words. Foreign patient and doctor information transfer carry through can be modeled as below Both foreign patient and the doctor can see every question in their native language and culture.4.1. Software This software can support all languages. When we fit a new language program XML file is extending. When we add a new language it will be located in this section en de tr fr new language code I have only migraine data for testing software in Turkish, French, German and English languages. Lets think that our doctor is a Turk and patient is a Fre nch native speaker. Doctor select question in his/her native language ikayetiniz nedir? and patient see this question in his native language Quest ce quil vous arrive ?. CultureStr for doctor is tr and for patient is fr. If we add a new language this section will be extend. and . binding shot5. ConclusionTranslations done by ad hoc interpreters and professional interpreters who does not know patients culture are equivalent according to the transfer of the knowledge but are not equal. Because of this, these are the translation of knowledge preferably than transfer of knowledge. Our solution can be a solution for knowledge transfer problems and limited all language proficiency. What we need is only questions for every complaint, what doctor are asking to their patients. It is not easy but if we do this, a visit to a foreign country will be much safe and a patient will have a chance to chose his/her doctor in which country he/she wishes. Every understanding may be a misunderstand ing because what we understand may be different from what is said by others. We understand equivalent of what said by others, not equal. By this project we are trying to extend understanding. As we mentioned before according to varied resources 80% of the medical mistakes are caused by wrong information (wrong information transfer). If we extend enough equivalent it will be nearly equal, at this point medical mistakes will decrease.6. creditWe gratefully acknowledge the support of Yaln Aytek stnda, Asst. Prof. Dr. Mehmet Erek, Didem Parlak, smail Cahit Grmez, Asst. Prof. Dr. Melike ahiner, Asst. Prof. Dr. ule -ncl, Prof. Dr. Zeynep Gven, Dr. Demet Din, Dr. -mer Aydn, Dr. nal Egeli, Senem Kayas, Dr. Suna Yldrm and Onur Uslu.7. References1 Alexander B., Perneger TV., Bovier PA., Loutan L., and Stalder H. Improving communication between physicians and patients who speak a foreign landuage. British daybook of public Practice 2003 53 541-546 2 Alexander B. and Hudelson P. Communicating With Foreign Language- Speaking Patients Is rag to maestro Interpreters Enough? Journal of Travel Medicine 2009 1-6 3 Collins KS., Hughes DL., Doty MM., Ives BL., Edwards JN., and Tenney K. various(a) Communities, Common Concerns Assessing Health Care Quality for Minority Americans. Findings from the Commonwealth memory board 2001 Health Care Quality Survey. in the buff York Commonwealth Fund. 4 Culler J. On Deconstruction, New York Cornel University Press 1982. 5 Galvez E and Stronks A (2007) Hospitals, Language, and Culture Joint Commusion International(http//www.jointcommission.org/NR/rdonlyres/E64E5E89-5734-4D1D-BB4D-C4ACD4BF8BD3/0/hlc_paper.pdf Last accessed Agust 2009) 6 Gale DD. ethnic Sensitivity Beyond Ethnicity A Universal Precautions Model. The cyberspace Journal of Allied Health Sciences and Practice 20064(1)1-5 7 Holden NJ. and Kortzfleisch HFOV. Why Cross- Cultural Knowledge Transfer is a Form of Translation in More ship canal Than You Think. Knowledge and Proc ess Management 2004 11(2) 127-136 8 Joint Commition International. http//www.jointcommission.org/SentinelEvents/SentinelEventAlert/sea_25.htm Last accessed June 2008 9 Joos SK., Hickam DH., Gordon GH., and Baker LH. 1996. make of Physician Communication Intervention on Patient Care Outcomes. Journal of General Internal Medicine 11(3) 147155 10 Karliner LS.,JAcops AE, Chen AH and Mutha S. Do Professional Interpreters Improve Clinical Care for Patients with Limited English Profeciency? A dictatorial Review of the Literature. Health Service Research 2007 42(2) 727-754 11 Kohn LT. Methods in Case orbit Analysis( Panel discussion conducted at the 1996 meeting of the Association for Health run Research) 1997. 12 Lee SM. A Review of Language and Other Communication Barriers in Health Care. Office of Public Health and Science 2003. 13 Packard, C.Finding Links between Healthcare Safety, Communication, and Cultural Norms and Assumptions. Carle Selected Papers 2009 Vol.50 No.2 55-58 (http //www.carleconnect.com/CSP/CSP%20Fall_Winter%2007/13.Packard.pdf Last accessed Agust 2009) 14 Perloff RM., Bonder B., Ray GB., and Ray EB. Doctor-Patient Communication, Cultural Competence, and Minority Health. American Behavioral Scientist 2006 49(6) 835-852 15 Vatrapu R., and Suthers D. Culture and Computers A Review of the creation of Culture and Implications for Intercultural Collaborative Online Learning. IWIC 2007 260-275 16 Hofstede G. And Hofstede GJ. Cultures and Organizations Software of the Mind. McGraw-Hill. 2005 17 Yin, R.K.Case Study Research, Design and Methods, 2nd ed. Newbury Park, sagacious Publications, 1994. 18 Hostede G.and Hofstede GJ. Cultures and Organizations Software of the Mind, Second Edition, McGraw-Hill, New York, 2005. 19 http//pgsi.com (Last accessed Agust 2009) 8. Corresponding Author Serkan Trkeli, Acbadem University, Faculty of Health Sciences, Department of Healthcare Management, Istanbul, Maltepe, Turkey,Tel(0090) 505 488 84 45, Fax(0090) 216 5 89 84 85 E-Mailemailprotected, Webwww.nasnim.com/serkanturkeli

No comments:

Post a Comment

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.